Showing posts sorted by date for query "bidmc spirit". Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query "bidmc spirit". Sort by relevance Show all posts

Sunday, March 02, 2014

In memoriam: Robert C. Moellering, Jr.

This announcement arrived from Harvard Medical School:

Dr. Robert C. Moellering, the HMS Shields Warren-Mallinckrodt Professor of Medical Research and a renowned infectious disease researcher, was physician-in-chief and chair of the Department of Medicine at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center from 1981 to 2005. He died on Feb. 24, 2014, at the age of 77.

Dr. Moellering made major advances in the investigation, treatment and prevention of infectious diseases, in particular studying the mechanisms of antibiotic action and bacterial resistance to antimicrobial agents. His work led to the development of laboratory tests that are now used worldwide. He was also the first to show the clinical effectiveness of penicillin-gentamicin combination therapy for enterococcal endocarditis, now the standard of care for this infection.

A dedicated teacher, researcher and clinician who trained generations of clinicians and academic physicians, Dr. Moellering’s career spanned more than four decades at HMS.

All true, but I'd like to add some more.

When I arrived as CEO of BIDMC in 2002, there was a lot of turmoil, but at the center of things stood a person of great integrity, calmness, and kindness.  He was not only Chief of Medicine, but he was also head of the faculty practice plan.  He had been Chief at New England Deaconess and was one of a very view "Deac" people to be asked to serve in a senior capacity in the newly merged hospital.  The reason for this was clear: Few people were as highly respected on "both sides of the aisle" as Bob.

I enjoyed working with him.  He was honest and clear, and his commitment to clinical care, research, and teaching were unmistakable.  Although he was in a leadership position, that position was not important to his self-image.  In an academic environment known for ego, he was remarkably unegotistical.  Perhaps that is why is was such a good teacher.  I remember attending a grand rounds session he taught about MRSA one day: In 45 minutes I learned more about the subject than I imagined possible. The talk was lucid, well organized, approachable regardless of your level of knowledge, and full of good humor and modesty about what was understood and what was still unknown.  That is was a substantive tour de force was no surprise given Bob's expertise. That it was a pedagogical tour de force was something else still.  I talked about it for days afterward.

As told on another blog:

I wanted to share two quotes from Dr. Moellering and a final one from Dr. Jerome Groopman delivered on the occasion of Dr. Moellering stepping down as Chair of Medicine.

“I served for the better part of 24 years as chairman of the department and also ran the faculty practice plan here. But I view administration as nothing more than a means to an end--a means to create more effective clinical and teaching programs in the department, and a way to ensure that I could have an impact on the training of physicians and the internal medicine house staff.”

“Teaching is the most important thing we do. Imparting knowledge to the next generation of physicians is incredibly important. It’s a privilege we are given in the academic setting. Not only does it give you a tremendous sense of satisfaction in that you’ve done something worthwhile, but it gives you some immediate gratification because you can watch students who go on to successful careers.”

Dr. Jerome Groopman: "How many of us has he supported on his shoulders? How many of us has he helped to move forward when we felt we didn't have the energy or endurance to continue? Those shoulders have carried enormous burdens, carried with a quiet confidence, through all the difficult times, the growth of the department, the merger…. Bob is loved because beyond his intellect, beyond his knowledge, beyond his hard work, he is filled with a unique form of kindness. Bob has true generosity of spirit. He sees your success as his success. This is his legacy."

At that same stepping-down party in June of 2005, Bob quoted a poem, and I asked if he would mind sending it to me.  He did, and I have saved the letter all these years:

Dear Paul:

The poem I quoted last Thursday evening was entitled "Ithaca," and was written by Constantine Cavafy.

"Hope the way is long.
May there be many summer mornings when,
With what pleasure, with what joy,

You shall enter first-seen harbors...

Keep Ithaca always in your mind.

Arriving there is what has been ordained for you.
But do not hurry the journey at all.
Better if it lasts many years;
And you dock an old man on the island,
Rich with all you’ve gained on the way,
Not expecting Ithaca to give you wealth.

Ithaca gave you the beautiful journey.

Without her you would not have set out.
She has nothing more to give you."


Bob entered many first-seen harbors, and some of us were lucky to travel with him for a portion of the voyage.

Sunday, January 12, 2014

Back to the future

I always look forward to giving a talk in Jim Conway's and Ron Goodspeed's physician leadership course at the Harvard School of Public Health, and today's class was no exception. The students--leaders from around the country--are interesting and attentive.  Moreover, Jim and Ron set up the framework for the class in a way that is always engaging.

But today, I was taken aback by their introductory remarks to my class session, which was a review of the turn-around I led at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in 2002 (using a case study prepared by Harvard Business School.)  The turn-around was necessary because of a failed merger within an ineffective corporate superstructure, the CareGroup system.  Truly, I have considered this "old news," but the instructors' remarks put the experience in a current context.  Harkening back to the mid-1990s, they noted that today's environment in health care is remarkably similar: a rush to mergers and acquisitions; financial pressures on hospitals; and big changes in the relationships between doctors and hospitals.

The class discussion stimulated my thinking abut the current scene.  While Partners Healthcare System will likely remain dominant for years to come in the Eastern Massachusetts market, it is interesting to observe other players and see how they plan to deal with the remainder of the market.  Merger fever seems to be the answer.  Let's take a gander:

Is it possible to be Switzerland?

Mt. Auburn Hospital in Cambridge is a high quality facility that has had excellent administrative and clinical leadership for many years.  Following a successful capital campaign supported by loyal constituents, it was able to upgrade and expand its buildings and equipment several years ago.  The focus on quality and safety has been exemplary, with outstanding results.  A long-standing, close relationship with its major physician organization has enabled the organization to do well under risk contracts.  On that front, too, MAH was an beneficiary of Blue Cross Blue Shield's "Alternative Quality Contract" in the early days, when BCBS padded first-year global payment budgets to entice hospitals and doctors to sign on.  Although MAH is part of CareGroup, its has been more like Switzerland.  While its doctors sometimes send higher acuity patients to affiliate BIDMC, they often choose PHS' Massachusetts General Hospital as a referral site.

This latter independence of spirit and practice is now up for grabs.  There have been thoughts recently that it is time for a formal merger of MAH with BIDMC.  These thoughts appear to be driven by expected financial pressures on MAH.  Some people apparently think that a merger would help alleviate the capital issues associated with renewal and replacement of physical plant and facilities. Creating a common bottom line between the two organizations, merging electronic medical records, and sharing in risk contracts would be the goal.  The expectation would be dramatically reduced tertiary "leakage" to the PHS system.

Beyond the normal administrative issues surrounding all mergers, this kind of shift in clinical practices could be viewed as problematic by MAH physicians.  Further, to the extent BIDMC must meet its own capital needs and those of its other new acquisitions, the process by which MAH could rely on access to capital could raise concerns among the loyal MAH community.

Is it possible in a world of ACOs for Mt. Auburn to remain as Switzerland, with relationships among a number of Boston area tertiary hospitals?  That's the underlying question for its administrative and clinical leadership and governing body.

How's the view up there?

New England Baptist Hospital, another CareGroup subsidiary, is nationally recognized for its prowess in orthopaedics.  Like MAH, it has also intensely focused on quality and safety issues and has an exemplary record in that regard.  On top of Parker Hill, separated by some distance from the hospitals in the Longwood area, NEBH has long suffered from lack of easy access to non-orthopaedic specialists who can be crucial to the care of complex patients (those with diabetes, heart disease, cancer, and the like.)  Other orthopaedic hospitals, like the Hospital for Special Surgery in New York, deal with this problem by adjacency to, or physical connection with, a general hospital (NY Presbyterian in the case of the HSS.)

Given the private practice model in place at NEBH, a full-scale merger with BIDMC is not likely.  But a real estate deal might be in the cards.  Sell that property at the top of Parker Hill--one of the best views in Boston--and use the proceeds to build a new pavilion on Longwood Avenue, connected to BIDMC. Integrate the electronic medical records systems and share the adjacent clinical specialists and tertiary facilities as needed.

Three's company?

There's talk all over town about a possible merger of BIDMC, Lahey Clinic, and Atrius Health (the state's largest multi-specialty practice.)  Such a merger is viewed by many as the ultimate book-end to the Partners System.

Gene Lindsey and I negotiated the first major affiliation between Atrius and BIDMC back in 2009, which resulted in a shift in tertiary and emergency care for thousands of patients from Brigham and Women's Hospital to BIDMC.  This partnership also produced the first generation of interoperability between our EHR systems.  Since then, the relationship has grown stronger and provides a foundation for more detailed talks.

There is a long-standing historical connection between BIDMC and Lahey based on Lahey's affiliation with the New England Deaconess Hospital years ago.  But, in recent years, the two organizations have been operating mainly in parallel--neither allies nor competitors.

A three-way merger here is a sophisticated and difficult negotiation. Assuming it makes sense on clinical and financial terms--something worth detailed and rigorous study--there are the following issues:

Leadership:  Only one of the current CEOs has operational experience in running a health care system.  Are the other two prepared to step aside, substantively, if not in title?

Governance:  Three very different kinds of boards are in place in the three entities.  What would be the desirable--and politically acceptable--form of the new governing body?  What would be the mix of lay versus clinical members?  What percentage of the board would come from each entity, or from outside all three?

Clinical direction:  Would this be a tertiary-care centric ACO, viewing the community doctors as referral sources?  Or would this be a primary-care centric ACO, viewing the hospitals as service organizations to the community doctors.

EMR:  What system would be put in place for interoperability of electronic medical records?  The "easy" path--buy an Epic system, the one used by Atrius--is fraught with high costs and loss of control to the vendor.  Is there an alternative that would work "well enough" and avoid the risk of an entirely new system?

Possible splintering within Atrius:  Atrius is a confederation of several multi-specialty practice groups.  While Harvard Vanguard is the largest, the others all have a role in governance.  Another large member, Reliant Medical Group, focuses on Central Massachusetts and relies on St. Vincent's Hospital as a tertiary referral center.  Whether Reliant or other parts of the alliance, will they agree enough on the world of the future to welcome a common bottom line with Lahey and BIDMC?

Thinking back to our class at HSPH today, I'm thinking there will lots of good case studies for Jim and Ron to present ten years from now.  It's too soon, though, to know whether the cases will be success stories or failures.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

Enid gives a gift on her birthday

Enid Shapiro was trained as a social worker, worked for years in that profession at the Beth Israel and BIDMC, and tonight she celebrated her 85th birthday by announcing a generous gift to our hospital. You see her here with daughters Amy and Laura and son Robert, but at the party she was surrounded by dozens of others, an extended "family" of people whose lives she has influenced.

Jane Matlaw, our head of community relations, reminisced and explained about the gift:


Thank you all for coming to this amazing birthday party honoring someone who is known and loved by so many . . . here in Boston, in many cities across the US, all over Israel and in many other parts of the world as well.

I met Enid Shapiro in 1977 when we were both on the board of what was then Area II Home Care in Roxbury. We became instant friends in addition to being social work colleagues. Enid was a force -- so smart, so outspoken and such an advocate for those who could not advocate for themselves. In the 33 years since I met her none of that has changed, and she certainly has not slowed down. I, like many others have learned so much from Enid.

While we were on the board of Area II Enid was diagnosed with breast cancer. Her attitude and strength and her faith in her medical providers at BIH (some of whom are here today) were extraordinary. Enid dealt with the news, went through the treatments and barely missed a beat. She took my breath away. In fact, she is the only woman whom I have met who liked her wigs so much that she decided to keep wearing them into and beyond her second breast cancer diagnosis in 1995 and still looks stunning in them to this day!

Enid has worked on many important social justice issues, and served on many boards and committees. From genetic privacy to the needs of elders; from Muslim/Jewish relations in Boston to Arab/Jewish relations in Israel; from helping organizations that she is passionate about including Keshet, NASW, Hadassah, JCRC, Kit Clark Senior Services, The Abraham Fund, Temple Sinai, The Brookline Literacy Project, Hebrew College, the Boston Opera Company and many, many more.

And, in her 85 years, she has more institutional memory and knows more of the history of many, many issues and who was involved in them than just about anyone I know. She even outlasted a few governors on the Governor’s Advisory Council on Aging.

But the bottom line is always about the people -- bringing people together to help understand different points of view, to help shape policy, to support a worthy cause or to take action together for the greater good.

And dayenu, all of this would and could have been enough in one heck of a productive life. But a few months ago Enid began thinking about doing even more, and in a big way. She told me that in appreciation of all of the extraordinary care she has received at BIDMC over the years, she wanted to make a gift, but she did not know exactly where it should go. It did not take long to figure out how to marry three loves of her life together: BIDMC, social work and Israel. So starting with a generous donation from Enid and the money that you have all contributed in honor of her 85th birthday, we are able to launch The Enid Shapiro Endowed Fund for Social Work Exchange. This fund will create a social work exchange program between social workers at BIDMC and Rambam hospital in Haifa, our sister city in Israel. We are truly indebted to Enid for this generous and meaningful gift which will, in the spirit of Enid, promote the understanding of many cultures in Boston and in Haifa.

On behalf of BIDMC, I thank you for this generous gift that will continue to open the eyes and improve on the skills of social workers across the globe to bring the best of care to all of the patients they will touch.

Thursday, October 07, 2010

Let us go forth, then, together

We held a "Latino Achievement Award Celebration" today to recognize the contributions and accomplishments of this large ethnic and cultural group in our community. The three people recognized were Ines de la Cruz, Dr. Leonor Fernandez, and Dr. Alvaro Pascual-Leone (seen here).

Each of the awardees gave a lovely talk to the audience, but I wanted to share Leonor's with you. She is a doctor in Healthcare Associates, our hospital-based primary care service. I include much of the text below, but I urge you also to watch the video below to get a better sense of the quiet power of her delivery.


I salute the true commitment to egalitarian quality health care at BIDMC evidenced in the many large and small decisions made daily by Russ, Paul, Jim, Tom, Mark, Louise, and many others here.

It is as a result of many of those decisions that I can spend a morning in HCA seeing, for example, a Columbian post-doc student with the flu; an elderly Iranian woman with heart failure; an intelligent Salvadoran woman with little formal education, who proudly tells me that her daughter is about to start college. I may see a wealthy middle aged Irish American man whose liver is failing due to hepatitis C, and a fit African American young lawyer with hypertension.

Without missing a beat, our team will triage them and treat them with equal respect and dignity. An interpreter will arrive on time to help us. If admitted, they will go to the same floors and be cared for by a dedicated and skilled group of nurses, hospitalists, social workers, techs, and food workers. They will be evaluated by a spectacular team of medical residents.

As one of my favorite poets, Jane Kenyon, has said, “It could be otherwise”.

Our ability to give intelligent, appropriate, and compassionate care will be tested, however. It will be tested by competing demands: by the complexity of therapy, by reimbursement structures, and by the pressures to do ever more in less time.

Our appreciation of cultural diversity and our commitment to egalitarian care is what will guide us. It must be our compass as we navigate the challenges of building systems and personnel that will enable each of us to give our best effort. Systems that support and ensure, for example, that we routinely speak to a patient –whether inpatient or outpatient—in a language they understand. Without continued attention to quality where the rubber meets the road, our best intentions run the risk of getting dropped, submerged into irrelevance by the more immediate pressures of our daily work.

I am proud to be a Latina, even if it is hard to define precisely what that means. Latin-America is a diverse continent, with a complex history flavored by the many cultures that emerged from sometimes violent collisions and from creative synergies. Cultures built on the legacy of Spanish Colonial times, the echoes of many ancient civilizations. Economies built on slavery and hard work, arrivals of newer immigrants, and the ever present influence of the powerful neighbour to the North. Latin American culture encompasses so many peoples, races and climates that it is as challenging to define it succinctly as it is to define a "U.S. culture".

And yet the word Latino retains meaning. I am honored and moved by the special affection and the warm words I feel and receive from Latinos in the cafeteria, from my patients, or from my colleagues here Alvaro and Ines. There is a recognition, an almost instant bond. It comes from a real love for the Spanish language, a sense of nostalgia or “saudade” (as the Brazilians would say) for a certain way of expressing affection, and perhaps from a shared sense of “otherness”—an implicit awareness of the daily struggle that so many face through language barriers, stereotype, or economic hardship. We may not each face all those barriers, but we bear witness to them, and we feel kinship.

The US is an incredibly inclusive and creative country. When I travel I find myself even more appreciative of the ability the U.S. has had to integrate so many peoples. But the US retains an ambivalence towards immigrants and towards other languages. These fears predictably raise their heads with every economic downturn—from Phoenix, Arizona, to Boston.

On the day after Sept 11, the French newspaper Le Monde published the headline, “We are all Americans”. The worldwide feeling of solidarity, of people standing with us, was palpable and deeply moving. That spirit of solidarity, that capacity to say, “I care about you--I respect you and stand by you,” is alive and well here at BIDMC. Through this award, we too say: “We are ALL Americans. We are all Latinos”.

Let us go forth, then, together.

If you can't see the video, click here.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Why am I here?

As I approach blog post number 2000, it is time for reflection. For those who remember the 1992 Presidential campaign, this is a bit like Admiral James Stockdale's comment, "Who am I? Why am I here?" (But, I hope with a more successful result!)

I'm going to skip the first question and go right to the second.

I joined BIDMC in 2002 to carry out a public service, to save a great academic medical center that had fallen on hard times. That done, we proceeded to develop strategic plans for our clinical, research, and educational missions. Those have been successfully implemented, with growth in market share and clinical affiliations, expansion of a world-class research program, and enhancement of both undergraduate medical education and residency programs.

The next phase was an intense focus on quality and safety improvement, combined with a level of transparency unprecedented for an academic medical center. The arrival of Mark Zeidel as our Chief of Medicine set the stage for this, as his is the largest department, and because he has a rabid enthusiasm for the proposition that hospitals should not harm patients. I personally took his objective a step further, by publishing real-time clinical data on this blog, on the theory that transparency would help us hold ourselves accountable to the standard we say we want to meet. The incumbent Chiefs of Service and others recruited after Mark enthusiastically jumped in. With our Board's involvement, we adopted an audacious goal of eliminating preventable harm over a four year period, and we are on track to reach that goal.

Meanwhile, we decided that the only way to excel as an institution was to engage front-line staff in all job categories in a sustained and respectful program of process improvement. We tested this out with BIDMC SPIRIT and then moved to full-fledged implementation of the Lean process improvement philosophy.

Most recently, we "discovered" that patients and their families need to be part of the planning and management of the hospital. If our purpose is to deliver the kind of care we would want for members of our own family, incorporating the unique perspective of patients and their families is the only way we can achieve that purpose.

So, from the institutional perspective, that's why I have been here. It is engaging and worthwhile to be the coach and cheerleader for a fine organization like ours as we make progress in carrying out our mission. If you had come to me in 2002, 2005, or 2008, that's the answer I would have given. But I have gone through an evolution as to why I am here as a person.

My answer now is that I am here to be with people like Tom (below and also seen here with his friends.) Tom was very sick. When he recovered, he asked me to help as he devoted himself to helping other current and potential patients. I am also here to be with people like Mary, who feel comfortable enough with me to share very personal observations of things going wrong -- hoping that it will lead us to change practices, reduce pain, and save lives. I am also here, from time to time, to join patients who are dying and to have open and heart-warming conversations about things that really matter.

In short, I have learned to be here to be emotionally present as part of the human condition. There is no more dramatic place in the world than a hospital. There is pathos, humor, pain, and relief. I have allowed myself to be open to the possibility that the CEO can play a role that is totally separate from the business aspects of the hospital. People choose to invite me into their lives to a degree that is truly humbling. They offer me the blessing that my presence is helpful to them and others. I am ever grateful for that.

Thursday, June 03, 2010

Poetry in action

Katherine Swan Ginsburg was a member of the BIDMC community as a house officer in the early 90s. Not long after completing her training she died of cancer at the age of 34. Katherine, whose mastery of medical knowledge and technical competence were outstanding, was also widely admired for her extraordinary compassion and selfless dedication in caring for her patients.

Over the last 18 years, Katherine’s family has kept her spirit alive through the Katherine Swan Ginsburg Humanism in Medicine Endowment Fund, which has played a key role in continuing to promote the importance of patient centered, compassionate care here at the BIDMC, something that has long been critical to our unwritten mission of taking care of patients as we would want members of our own families to be taken care of.

Today's lecture was offered by Rafael Campo, a member of our faculty, whom regular readers may remember. He was a key force in organizing this week's events on humanism in medicine, which overlapped the poetry slam mentioned below. His topic was "Cultural Competence: Poetry and the Importance of Voice in the Illness Experience."

Here are some video excerpts of Rafael's lecture. Beneath his video is a short take of some of the art on exhibit as part of the Medical Humanities Week Celebration. If you can't see the videos, click here.



Tuesday, March 09, 2010

Crystal clear compassion

Kevin Cullen sensitively writes this column in today's Boston Globe about Crystal Sannella and her colleagues from BIDMC who recently went on a medical mission to Haiti.

I've had the privilege of getting to know some of these folks, and I am struck by their generosity of spirit. You can see this, too, in the post-mission emails among them and to those of us in hospital administration. Here are some excerpts from three:

Now that we are all back from Haiti, I just wanted to take a minute to say again what an honor it was to work beside all of you this last week. Despite conditions that really defy description, you each worked tirelessly to provide the absolute best quality of care possible given the circumstances of the situation, and I - and the patients and families we cared for - appreciate that. Surrounded by such devastation and tragedy, it would have been easy to despair; yet each of you managed in different and unique ways to create something positive in an otherwise bleak reality, always acting professionally and with compassion.

The experiences we have had will all make us better in our own roles and appreciate the resources we do have to provide great clinical care at BIDMC. I have no doubt that there are many more people alive this week who would not have been had we not been there. There were unfortunately a lot of deaths as well, but having reviewed every case, I can honestly say that nothing more could have been done in the clinical situations you were all in. You have touched the lives of many and they were grateful for it -- evidenced by the fact they did not want us to leave.

[This trip] was shocking, tragic, exciting, challenging, inspiring, and memorable -- sometimes discouraging, but ultimately immensely gratifying. We were all frustrated and saddened by the limits of what we could do, but despite those limits I think we were able to do some very good work. I'm also especially grateful that as a very junior member of the department I was given the opportunity to help. It was a profound experience for me, and I hope very much that I can make international work a significant part of my practice in the future.

Tuesday, February 02, 2010

Bearing witness to Haiti

My friend Jeff Swartz, the CEO of Timberland, recently took his company plane to Haiti to help deliver relief supplies and personnel. What he saw left a searing impression. I share excerpts of his note to his staff. (To supplement Jeff's letter, I present this picture of Faina. Hers was one of several lives saved by BIDMC and other doctors last week. Story here.)

Last week, I visited Haiti, in the company of Bill Shore, the founder and executive director of Share Our Strength, and a Timberland Board member, and chair of the Board's Corporate Social Responsibility Committee, and in the company of Wyclef Jean, a 12 time Grammy award winner, a Haitian musician and activist, Timberland’s partner in an effort to plant trees and reforest Haiti, as part of our global Earthkeeper efforts. The visit was in response to the earthquake that struck Haiti 3 weeks ago; our visit was an attempt to focus Timberland’s Earthkeeper resources temporarily on disaster relief. The trip was emotional and powerful; I left Saturday night and was back in the office Tuesday.

So, what’s so hard about a brief note that describes the heroism of the many doctors we saw, the heartbreak of the destruction we saw, the inspiration I felt with Bill and Wyclef, and the indignation I felt at the world’s well intended but inept efforts to cope with this disaster?

Maybe it is the scale of the disaster, in the context of a country already ravaged by history. Maybe it is the raw, emotional experience of being amidst death and destruction, and in the presence of the dying. Maybe it is the feeling of futility that waited for me at each stop we made in Haiti. Yes, we made a difference, but we did not even scratch the surface of the pain and agony.

For all these reasons and more, I have not done my job by you; I have not been able to bear witness to you from Haiti. So, below, I have tried to right that wrong. Call this note, “bearing witness” -- but “bear with me” also works -- it is a very long note. Long for the reasons I cite above, and long because it is hard even now for me to say simply why a bootmaker flew to Hell and how the experience of that Hell affirmed my belief in the mission of commerce and justice. So, here goes:

1.30am Saturday night in Manchester, NH. One backpack, with no change of clothes, just a camera, a notebook, malaria pills, and my Bible. Drove to Manchester with Billy Shore; not a lot of chit chat.

On the plane, Wyclef Jean was waiting, exhausted before the trip began. He was going back to Haiti for the 2nd time since the quake — many of you saw him on CNN two nights after the disaster, with his wife, telling stories about transporting 10s of dead bodies to temporary morgues. Wyclef is a man of many faces — we know him as a musician and a celebrity, for sure, but if I jump ahead and tell you about Wyclef by the end of this voyage, I would speak of an immensely gentle, noble, powerful man — one part dreamer, one part prophet, one part revolutionary.

And on the plane, strangers -- physicians from Partners in Health. When the earth shakes and the flimsy medical infrastructure disappears — PIH calls on physicians and nurses and medical students — and they drop what they are doing, like the doc from San Francisco on our plane, like the med student from New York…they pack their backpacks, grab whatever medical supplies they can round up…and we meet them, 1.30am, bound for Hispaniola.

(After arrival, a helicopter trip to Haiti.)

From the air, in a little over an hour or so, you flit across beautiful inspiring mountains and along magnificent beaches, from the Dominican Republic to Haiti. There is a large lake that demarcates between the two countries, on the route we flew, but you don’t need a map to know where one world ends and another begins. The lush agriculture on one side of the lake leads to a more hardscrabble agriculture on the other; the big (ok, functional) highway on the DR side leads to one lane each way winding on the other. We can see the aid trucks crawling along on the Haiti side. And in minutes, Port au Prince looms ahead, dense, destroyed, honestly not to be believed, from the air. A densely packed city, an up and down city of folded hills, and everywhere you can see…cataclysm. You have a city that started with basically no functioning infrastructure – and then the whole darn thing falls down. So what’s left? A world of pain, and human spirit.

First stop, Cite Soleil – the City of the Sun – which is the worst slum in Port au Prince. Clef says, not a lot of blanche (white people) in Cite Soleil ever; should be interesting. Just what I’m looking for — interesting. Because as the convoy weaves through the city, I am reduced to holding the video camera in my lap and filming my knee. I can’t believe the physical destruction. Nor the swarm of humans walking. People walking in the streets — this is one of the overwhelming images of this voyage. Where are they going? What are they seeking? Walking, everywhere. Streets choked with dust and detritus and despair, and folks out walking. Whole blocks just leveled.

Our convoy pulls to the curb under the bluest sky and with the blazing sun as witness. Within 30 seconds of Clef’s appearance on the sidewalk, there are ten thousand young people around us. On a retaining wall in front of us, clogging the wide street, everywhere the eye can see. Beatles en route to Shea Stadium; I’ve never seen a crowd like this, form this fast, be this close.

We are in the Cite to feed the hungry. We’ve already seen a UN convoy heading from the airport to distribute food and water—white armored personnel carriers, soldiers in body armor and combat gear, turret gunners manning loaded weapons, sirens blaring, trucks roaring through the clogged streets—to hand out 50 lb bags of rice. Clef reminds me that good intentions don’t feed people. 50 lbs of rice not all that helpful, when there is no pot, no cooking fire, and no clean water anywhere with which to cook the rice. The Yele model is a little different—we brought food from the DR, food that Yele purchased, and somehow, in this destroyed city, Clef’s team cooked 8,000 hot meals of Haitian cuisines (goat stew). Someone “found” 8,000 styrofoam take-out trays, from one of the destroyed restaurants somewhere in town. And found a truck. Here’s the truck, here’s the meals, here’s Clef with a bullhorn shouting in Creole, and here is a mighty river of the hungry, lining up to be fed. With sweat pouring off of everyone, we began to hand out the meals.

We are working hard in the sunny version of hell, but despite everyone’s best efforts, of a sudden, it starts to get tense. The Yele volunteers are shouting at the folks in line in Creole, "Don’t push, don’t push," but you could see in the eyes of the mothers and the fathers and the children, everyone watching the pile of cooked meals in the back of the truck get smaller and smaller and a sense of despair and maybe even panic begin — will I get a meal for my child before they run out? And so all of a sudden, the business of Sunday lunch heads in the wrong direction — the river of hungry humans becomes a raging river, pressing forward, starting to crush each other and us. And so the security guys – with good intentions – shove themselves in front of us, and everyone started taking out their weapons and I heard safeties being taken off and I knew we were not far from a really bad situation.

At this point I was crushed behind a wall of security people, up against the open back of the truck. In front of me, not 3 humans deep away, there was a little girl. And someone must have stepped on her or something – she started to cry. In the raging ocean of human suffering—her tears and her fear was too much for me. So I reached between 2 security guys and put my hand on her and shouted in French,”Its ok, I’m gonna get you.” I couldn’t lift her up; I was wedged too tightly -- but now I was back in CEO mode and so I said to the security guy in front of me, “Get me that little girl.” And he did -- lifted her up and passed her back to me and I held her tight, in my arms, and she was sobbing and so was I. I held onto her, maybe 8 years old, talking to her in French, and after about 30 seconds she stopped crying. Because the crushing that was hurting her — that’s gone now. I’m holding her and we’re behind a security guy and so she’s not going to get crushed. So she stopped crying.

My view of the world says, she should have still been crying. But her view of the world is, no. I may not have a home, I may be hungry, I may be living in hell – but that’s normal. That isn’t worth crying over. If someone is hurting me on top of all that, then I’ll cry. I handed her a meal and off she went – as if to say, I’m going back to the normal despair of my day and I can handle that, don’t need your help, thanks a million and have a good day.

We went back to handing out the food. The crush didn’t go away, but the fear of a bad scene did. I’m still kinda pinned against the truck; from under the truck, a little brown hand reaches out and grabs my cargo calf. I look down, and there is a little hand clutching my leg. Can’t see the child — he or she has crawled through the densest crush of people I’ve ever seen, wriggled under the truck, and grabbed me — signaling, "I beat the line, now give me a meal." I slipped one down to the hand; the hand grabbed it and vanished. My heart still has not come back — a child, figuring out how to get a meal.

From Cite Soleil we drove through destruction towards Bel Air, our next destination. Nothing belle about Bel Air; the sun is starting to wane in the sky, birds are chirping, but this neighborhood is destroyed, concrete smashed like you cannot imagine.

When we get there, Wyclef disappeared to talk to some of Bel Air’s residents and I was left standing there with Billy, and feeling the smell. One of the security guys said to me, “You know what that smell is, right?” And I’m thinking no, but I bet you’re gonna tell me and he said, “That’s dead people.”

When Clef came back he said, “Smells bad,” and I am quick to agree, but he says, “No – it smells really bad. No rescue teams have come here. No rescue teams will ever come here.” If there was some way someone was still alive amidst the rubble in this corner of this sad city, they were left to die. Clef led us here because he had work to do to try and negotiate with angry young men, no more violence. And while he worked at that, I kept an unwilling vigil with the dead.

We left Bel Air, but in my heart, I can still see it and hear it and smell it. Leaving them there, men, women and children entombed in rubble – it’s just not right.

Our convoy headed up into the hills. Billy asked me, "Where are we gonna sleep?" One of the guys who has been driving us around says, "Come to my house, you can sleep there." He has an undamaged house? He does, higher up in the hills. And so, Haitian rhythm — I got a little girl’s bed, with teenage movie stars taped to the wall, and Barney the purple dinosaur on little girl sheets, and Billy got the room that belonged to the older daughter. Security guys sleeping on the dining room table and living room chairs.

I sent my kids one last note, opened my Bible and studied for 15 minutes, and was asleep in my clothes with my boots on without even realizing it for 4 precious hours — no dreams, no thoughts, dark and silent and asleep.

Dawn was signaled by the roosters and a rosy sunrise. We headed downtown to University Hospital, the biggest hospital in Port au Prince.

We found a mixture of desperation and dignity like I’ve never encountered. In the sweltering sun, big strong young men and women from the 82nd Airborne, taking care of business — securing the hospital, and helping the PIH doctors. We watched a big blond trooper from somewhere shoulder his M4, and bend down to pick up an old woman who was too sick to walk any further, and carry her with dignity and caring to the triage station in the bright heat — a grey file cabinet resting on its side. We watched the medics triage the sick, and then we walked into the hospital itself.

How shall I tell you what we saw? Civil War technology, 21st century doctors, pain and suffering, grace and dignity. Post operative “wards,” nothing more than cots stacked in the open air, every single patient having experienced at least one amputation from the crush injuries that could not be treated otherwise. David Walton, a young PIH physician told me as we walked through, we have saved their lives to this point by amputation — but 100% of the patients you see are real mortality risks. When they are “discharged,” which they have to be — we have many many more behind them waiting for these cots — where will they go? How will they be kept free of infection?

A surgeon from New York showed us the “operating theater,” a medium sized storage room that hadn’t fallen down in the quake. Four army cots, propped up on blocks, so the surgeons wouldn’t have to bend un-naturally. IV’s hanging from the what looked like repurposed coat racks. Most of what they were still doing was amputations. Because after enough time has passed and wounds haven’t been treated, there’s just nothing else you can do.

They told us, when children came in hurt, they cast them as quickly as they can in order to immobilize the victim -- because in some of the crush injuries, if you move it you could take out blood vessels and someone could bleed out. So they immobilize with casts, but then when it comes time to deal with the actual injury, the cast needs to come off again. Do you know what you can’t take a fiberglass cast off with? Scissors. Scissors don’t cut through fiberglass — and so the docs can’t get to the wounds. Because you need a cast saw, and guess what? They didn’t have one at University Hospital.

Dr Dave said, “We’ve really got to find a cast saw,” and I said, what do you mean, find? And he said, “Well, we know they have cast saws at the airport, we’ve been sending SOS messages for 4 days and we can’t get them here.” Not 5 miles away. So now I’m all ready to go storm the airport and thankfully Billy Shore said he had a better idea … whipped out his iPhone – can you see the irony of standing in this place and Billy’s on his iPhone? And he sent a note on Twitter that said, “Anybody got a surgical cast saw I could use?” and the network goes whacko and an hour later there are 3 of them being Fed Exed to Yele Haiti people because they’ll do whatever they have to to get aid to those who need it.

Before I left for this hastily-planned trip, people – many of them rightfully disgruntled family members – demanded to know what I hoped to accomplish with my visit. I always replied, honestly, that I didn’t know and wouldn’t know until it happened ... but that I had faith that we would find a way to share strength. A week later, and plenty of tears later, I am still not sure.

Yele would have served the meals without me. University Hospital would have gotten a cast saw, eventually. Somehow, nothing I did would have gone undone. So CEO as disaster volunteer, not a good model. But, CEO as witness — that is a different story.

What my eyes have seen, my heart has felt. And so this voyage is just beginning.

The good that comes from this journey lies rather in what happens next.

It lies in the limitless kindness of Bill Shore — who worked his cell phone to reach Senator Bob Kerrey, the Congressional Medal of Honor winner from Nebraska, who lost his leg in combat in Vietnam, and who spent more than the last decade building a prosthetic “industry” in Vietnam, so his former enemies could have prosthetic care for their wounds. Billy used to work for Kerrey, and moved by what he saw — 70% of Haiti is young people, and so 70% of the amputees face a life long challenge of prosthesis — Billy persuaded Kerrey to begin to set up a prosthetic network in Haiti. Lives will be saved and destinies altered by this kindness.

We are working with Yele, to ensure that the pipeline from the DR to Haiti is open and working, so aid can go not to a UN depot, but to the people who need it so desperately.

And, Yele and Timberland are continuing to work together, more intimately than either imagined, to set up an operationally sound approach to helping our brothers and sisters in Haiti. I’ll be back in touch with more information as our partnership continues to evolve, and to share with you the ways in which we’re hoping to bring our vision of commerce and justice to bear for Haiti’s citizens and survivors.

Thank you for bearing witness to my experience by reading this far. I wish I could leave some of this out; I wish most of it hadn’t happened. Thank you for kind words you’ve shared; I needed your strength and I still do. Most of all, thank you for building a community at Timberland whose values give me license for such a journey -– not in an indulge-the-crazy-CEO way, but in a “of course you should go, why are you still standing here?” way.

No clever conclusion to write — because this voyage is hardly begun. Home from hell, changed and different, but unrelenting in my view that the path to heaven lies true north by commerce and justice.

Yours in service,

Jeff

Sunday, January 31, 2010

Keeping it going for Haiti

A note last week to the BIDMC staff. Readers of this blog can join in, too!

To: BIDMC Community
From:Eric Buehrens, Chief Operating Officer and Executive Vice President
Lisa Zankman, Senior Vice President, Human Resources
Subject: New Team Fund Raising for Haiti Relief

Earlier this week, our Development staff presented a check for $33,616 to Partners in Health for relief efforts in Haiti. Thanks to the almost 150 members of the BIDMC Community who donated through Grateful Nation.

It has become clear that supporting the Haitian people is going to be a long-lasting labor of love, determination and hope. The lives of our colleagues who lost family members and friends have been changed forever. Over the coming months and years, BIDMC clinicians and other relief workers will no doubt return again and again and still find so much that needs to be done.

To help with the ongoing efforts, BIDMC has been inspired by a group of medical residents, unit nurses and other staff, and their supporters who have started a little friendly competition to raise money for Haiti relief.

We’ve built a space on Grateful Nation for their efforts. In addition, anyone at BIDMC can now start a team to track fund-raising, seek other supporters and spread the competitive spirit.

To start a team, join one or support one that is already started, click here. Thank you for all your generosity.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Judy gave the patient her own insulin

Here is an email from Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, Jr, Division Chief, Trauma, Burn, and Surgical Critical Care at Brigham and Women's Hospital to our chief of surgery and me:

Dear President Levy and Dr. Hurst,

As part of a multidisciplinary multihospital team, I had the honor and privilege to work alongside one of BIDMC's outstanding nursing professionals as part of the first wave of Partners in Health medical response to the earthquake relief in Haiti. As a trauma nurse, Judy was invaluable as she courageously worked under the most austere environment to provide care to the impoverished who suffered open fractures, compartment syndrome, and sepsis. Equipped with little more than a stethoscope, some drugs, and an indomitable spirit, Judy provided indefatigable care to countless patients in the postoperative recovery unit.

Her greatest gift to her patients was her compassion. One selfless act stands out among many. One of our patients had blood sugars that were so high that they were unmeasurable on the glucometer. There was no insulin available. Judy gave the patient her own insulin. With nursing professionals like Judy, it was a privilege to serve the people of Haiti.

Sincerely,

Selwyn O. Rogers, Jr, MD, MPH

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Forming bonds between Atrius Health and BIDMC

Last week, I sent this staff email following up on our earlier announcement about the new clinical partnership between Atrius Health and BIDMC. It gives you a sense of how we are preparing for this joint venture, but also provides the broader context. Gene Lindsey's comment holds even more power in light of the direction of recent legislative activity in Washington, DC.

Dear BIDMC,

As you may have read a few weeks ago, Atrius Health and BIDMC have entered into a new patient care partnership. Starting January 4, patients from the Harvard Vanguard Kenmore, Copley, and Post Office Square Centers will be coming here for emergency care and tertiary care. We have had teams from both organizations working for months on the logistics and planning for this, and we are in good shape to proceed. (For example, read John Halamka's blog for details of some of the items involved in the IT arena.)

We had a welcoming reception last night in the Shapiro lobby, and it was a great chance for clinicians, administrators, and board members from both institutions to get together and to celebrate the work that has gotten us this far. It was striking how many of these folks already had relationships, some dating back to their training days.

Over the coming days and weeks, you will see some new people from Atrius on our floors as this rolls out, especially hospitalists and case managers, but also people in specialty areas. I know you will make them feel welcome. And I am absolutely confident that patients from Atrius will see the same level of care we strive for all the time, the kind of care we would want a member of our own family to receive. But, we want this to be more:

Gene Lindsey, the Atrius CEO, and I have met with each other's senior management team, and we have a simple and a hard message for both organizations. We aim for this partnership to set a new standard for patient care in the region. As a tertiary center, we plan to be exceptionally responsive to the primary care-centered model of care exemplified by Atrius (and also enhancing how we do so with our own superb primary care practices at Healthcare Associates, APG, and the community health centers). Together, we look forward to setting higher bars in safety and quality, aided by transparency. We will also work together using the philosophy, measures, and techniques of the Lean process to improve the work environment for all.

(In that regard, I am officially declaring the end of BIDMC SPIRIT, which was an inward-looking approach to process improvement. SPIRIT was based on Lean principles, and we learned a lot from it. But we now start to enter a different phase of process improvement, one based on JOINT action with our clinical partners, starting first with Atrius. In the last few months, Alice Lee and her team have been teaching us more about Lean. Many of you have participated in rapid improvement events and other training. That will continue, but, in Atrius, we have a partner who has been engaged in similar training, and we aim to learn from one another and apply this philosophy to our joint operations.)

More broadly, Gene recently addressed aspects of our mutual goal in a newsletter to his staff. He noted:

“How do we reform healthcare?” That is a big tough question. This week I heard Don Berwick from the Institute for Healthcare Improvement point out that the question in Washington has shifted toward, “How do we reform health insurance?” By changing the question, the President is indicating his understanding of the limits of legislation. He understands that politicians can change the way people access care, or how care is financed, but they cannot change how care is delivered and legislators will always find it difficult to create quality.

Politicians can increase the funding of health care, but a reform of the practice of healthcare is our domain. Only we, the community of practice, can improve quality and change the systems of care in such a way as to improve the experience of care for individuals, improve the health of the nation and end the extortion of much needed funds from the other categories of our collective societal experience. Only we, the good people who provide the care, can create the solutions that end the fragmented, mediocre and unsafe experience of care that is the experience of so many of our citizens.


We control the experience of health care for our patients far more than we might want to admit. Since so often they do exactly what we tell them to do when we suggest a test, or a surgery, we need to be very sure that we try to see the world as they do as we give them our counsel. Being patient-centered is the hardest task we have because for many of us it means trying very hard to convince patients that they should do what we think is best.


What gets done is usually what we order. The options that most patients have are the ones that we offer. Their experience of care is the experience we provide. If we care about our patients, the first question that must be answered is “What do they really really want?”


Note that the focus here is what patients really want. They do not want MRIs, CT scans, or procedures. They want to live happy and healthy lives. They want us to listen to them and understand their needs. This was put so clearly by Dr. Amy Ship, when she recently accepted the Compassionate Caregiver Award from the Schwartz Center. Please take 8 minutes to watch and listen to Amy's speech, here.

Gene and I are excited about the Atrius-BIDMC partnership because we think it provides a vehicle for learning how to do this and for spreading the word to our community. We invite you to join this adventure and be active participants.

Sincerely,
Paul

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Caller-Outer of the Month Award #7


Continuing our series, our Board of Directors awarded this month's caller-out award to Marylou Conant, RN, who works in our PACU (i.e., post-op area.) Regular readers will recall that this award is presented by the Board to reinforce the underlying concept of BIDMC SPIRIT -- that each person should be encouraged to call out problems in the workplace and be recognized and appreciated for his or her contribution to safety, quality, efficiency, and a better work environment.

Marylou's call-out was related to the availability and location of Calstat hand cleansing pumps. She noticed that hand hygiene in the PACU was being impaired. Why? The issue is that patients in the PACU are in bays that are close together, and you approach the patient from the foot-end of the bed. The Calstat dispensers are mounted at the head of the bed, on the wall, a location that does not support ease of good hand hygiene. But each bed does have a mobile bedside table that you pass on your way to the patient. Marylou and her colleagues figured out that you could "set a location" for a Calstat dispenser on every mobile bedside stand. They came up with a simple but elegant solution that provides both a visual cue as well as a slip-proof location on the mobile table using simple magnetic strips.

Marylou received a congratulatory letter, plus second row dugout tickets to a Red Sox game of her choice.

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Lean: Tortoise not Hare


Here's an update for those of you interested in our process improvement efforts at BIDMC and our preliminary thinking about the next stages. Back in March 2008, we rolled out our BIDMC SPIRIT program, our first formal experiment with staff-based call-outs based loosely on the Totoya Production System, aka "Lean." It has accomplished some good stuff, and we have learned from it. (Search "BIDMC SPIRIT"and "Caller-Outer" on this blog to see a collection of those items.)

From the very beginning, we said that BIDMC SPIRIT would itself evolve, and now we are at the latter stages of thinking through how to do it. This process included some in-depth training of several of our senior clinical and administrative leaders, a cadre of the next organizational level of directors, and several of our medical trainees. Beyond training us, those sessions served as test beds for the specific curricula developed by our staff, in cooperation with and building on materials from the Greater Boston Manufacturing Partnership. Meanwhile, too, Steve Spear invited several of our folks to audit his process improvement class at MIT, where they have had more advanced exposure to Steve's work but also healthy interactions with people from other industries.

As the graphic above displays, we view ourselves at the very beginning of a long journey to full implementation of Lean principles in our hospital. Others, exemplified by Gary Kaplan and his colleagues at Virginia Mason Medical Center in Seattle, and John Tuissaint at Thedacare, started earlier and are further along.

As I was discussing with Jim Womack the other day, it is an interesting paradox that while an important part of the Lean philosophy is the concept of standardizing work (to avoid waste and unnecessary variation), when it comes to implementation of Lean, each organization is essentially sui generis. That is, the plan for diffusing the concepts of Lean in an institution like ours has to be cognizant of the people and the culture of the place, an environment that has evolved over decades.

The idea here is to be slow and steady -- "Tortoise not Hare" -- in both planning for implementation and executing the plan. I present, for your viewing, a simplified chart of the roll-out proposal we are currently thinking about and will be sharing with our leadership groups and staff. You can click on that chart and expand it. You might not get all the points, but you can see the major themes: Lots of training; application by the trainees of what they have learned; focus on broad system work across the hospital, but also specific project work in high priority areas; and a small, nimble governance structure to keep track of things and make mid-course corrections.

I hope, by presenting these materials here, to encourage others of you who have been through this kind of transformation to submit comments to share your experiences, and to encourage those who are thinking about doing this to reach out to others who are in mid-stream. As the US considers its options with regard to health care reform, the real action will remain in each hospital and physician group. Public policy instruments are blunt and imprecise. Unless we take charge of the manner in which we do our work, the broad general policies being considered in Washington, DC will make very little difference in the quality of care and the efficiency with which it is delivered.

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Summer Report to the BIDMC Staff

Regular readers know that I believe in administrative, as well as clinical, transparency in our hospital. I have trouble understanding why this is unusual, but I know that it is. I just can't imagine trying to solve the problems of an organization and having a common sense of purpose and direction unless everybody is aware of what's going on.

Many of you followed our efforts of dealing with a budget shortfall earlier this year. I sent out the following email to the staff yesterday to offer a follow-up.

Dear BIDMC,

Back in March, I promised I would report back to you on budget and financial issues in June. Here we go:

First, here are the details of our progress in the current fiscal year. As a result of the steps we all took together, we expect to break even for this year. What could have been a $20 million loss has been eliminated. With your help, what could have been 600 layoffs was reduced to 70 layoffs. With your extra help, we were able to insulate our lower wage staff members from what could have been particularly bad news. BIDMC has received national acclaim for our approach to solving these budget problems, and our story has caused many organizations and institutions around the country to think of more humane ways to deal with the economic downturn.

When I asked for your help back in March, I was confident of the response. But I honestly did not understand the enthusiasm with which it would come. I knew that we viewed ourselves as a family here. But I did not fully understand the degree of affection and mutual commitment that underlays our hospital. We together lived through something very special, and I was especially honored to be your CEO during those weeks.

What now? I will talk about next year's budget, but first want to give an overview, at least as I see it. First, some "business school" type of background. I apologize if this is a bit dense and financially technical, but it will be helpful for you to understand the overall picture. I have also provided embedded links to my blog on some of the topics I mention, in case you want to delve into them further. Stick with me through this, please -- even if some of the terminology is new to you -- because I would really like you to understand the financial environment in which we carry out our important societal missions of patient care, research, and education.

As an academic medical center, we have been engaged in a successful business strategy that is composed of five elements: (1) create a broad referral network of trusting primary care doctors, specialists, and community hospitals; (2) emphasize those high level tertiary and quaternary specialties in which we excel, where we can gain market share, and which are highly reimbursed; (3) create a thriving environment for clinical care, research, and education that makes us attractive for the world’s leading clinicians and researchers; (4) negotiate favorable insurance reimbursement packages with insurance companies; and (5) pursue unrestricted philanthropy and gifts directed at clinical, research, and educational priorities.

We have had specific financial targets during this period. To renew and replace infrastructure in our buildings, to stay up to date with the latest clinical equipment, and to invest in our research enterprise, we should be prepared to make annual capital investments in the range of 130% of depreciation, or about $90 million per year. To generate this kind of cash, we need to earn a sustained operating margin of at least 4% supplemented by philanthropy directed specifically to capital purposes. In the years following the merger of the Deaconess and the BI, the hospital’s finances suffered, and capital investment did not meet this standard. Following the turn-around in 2002, we were able to earn a sufficient margin to start to make up for this shortfall, and by FY2008, we had substantially narrowed the gap on a cumulative basis.

There is nothing on the national or state political and economic scene to suggest that the coming years will offer good news for us and for other hospitals. Unless we act decisively, it is reasonable to expect a slow and steady deterioration in our capital position, our ability to compete, and ultimately our ability to carry out our mission in a manner that meets the standard of excellence we demand for ourselves. Putting aside the ups and downs of the economy, there are two major reimbursement factors that are likely to come into play. First, the rate of increase in reimbursements from both the government and private insurers will, at best, rise at the overall rate of consumer spending (not medical sector inflation). Academic medical centers like ours will especially see this. Second, there will be a tendency on the part of both types of insurers to move more to a capitated or bundled form of insurance that will require allocation of revenues and risk between the hospital and its affiliated doctors, but also between those two groups and other institutions in continuum of health care delivery (e.g., skilled nursing facilities and rehabilitation centers.) In others words, there will be something like an annual budget per person for health care, as opposed to the current fee-for-service type of pricing, where we get paid for each diagnosis and procedure and treatment we offer.

So, notwithstanding several years of success based on this business model, we need to recognize that the coming period will introduce new pressures on BIDMC. It is hard to envision exactly how we should respond to those changes. But we know, directionally, what we need to do:

1) We need to retain and enhance our focus of safety and quality and eliminating harm to patients. Beyond the obvious humanitarian reason for doing that, there is also a business imperative. We should anticipate that there will be greater public policy pursuit of quality and safety improvements, most likely characterized by failure to pay for certain procedures with adverse outcomes (e.g., “never” events and returns for follow-up surgery). There is also likely to be discounting of the capitated rates referred to above for failure to meet defined safety and quality metrics. These punitive steps add impetus to the existing business incentives for pursuing quality and safety improvement. Those incentives are expansion of market share from referring sources who value quality and safety and the dollar savings that accrue to the hospital by avoiding costs associated with patient harm.

2) We need to improve the way we organize work at the hospital to make it more efficient and less expensive. We have taken some baby steps in this direction with BIDMC SPIRIT. This program incorporates "Lean" type of thinking by encouraging people to call out problems in the work place, analyze those problems to their root cause, and invent solutions. If done right, this kind of continuous process improvement makes a safer and more pleasant workplace for our staff. When I started up SPIRIT, I told you that the design and approach of the program itself would change over time as we learned from it. Many of you joined in with enthusiasm and accomplished some great things, but then you felt that the effort had reach a plateau and sagged over time. Indeed it did because we recognized that we had not done sufficient training -- particularly of managers -- to give them the support they need to make it work. So stay tuned for more on that front.

3) We need to create stronger relationships with the insurers (especially Blue Cross, Harvard Pilgrim, and Tufts Health Plan) to ensure that our quality control and efficiency programs are recognized by them and rewarded in reimbursement methodologies.

4) We need to enhance and expand our clinical relationships with community hospitals and multi-specialty groups to provide a specific focus on quality and safety, to ensure that patients get the right type of care in the right place, but also to provide a dramatic improvement in the communication about patients' needs and the status of their care.

What does this mean this summer as we prepare our budget for FY2010? There are lots of moving parts. We will soon announce some new clinical affiliations in the community, and those will bring additional patients and revenue to BIDMC. But the reimbursement changes that are headed our way mean that we cannot just continue to spend money in the historical way to serve those patients. We need to organize our work differently to reduce overuse of testing and clinical procedures, some of which have been profitable in the past. We need, too, to be attentive to the levels of staff we need in various functional areas -- increasing some and diminishing others -- but doing so in a way that incorporates your suggestions for improving work flow and creating a safer environment. Because of financial pressures on the clinical side of the house, the margins that have traditionally supported research have shrunk, and so researchers too will have to meet more explicit financial targets. We will be gradually redesigning our education program so that efficiency, quality, and safety in clinical functions is more explicitly supported by our house staff, something that will also enhance the academic value of our training programs.

I recognize that these are just generalities at the moment, and you probably want to know, "What does this mean for me?" The nature of these global changes is that we all will see effects on our work lives, but they cannot be predicted exactly. Some people find that exciting, and some people find that scary. It will be a little of both. What I can promise you as we go through this is that we will do it together, with everybody sharing all the same information, with lots of opportunity for consultation and participation. The truly great organizations, like ours, are not afraid to face the future when we know we are doing it together.

Sincerely,

Paul

Paul F. Levy
President and CEO

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Caller-Outer of the Month Award #6


Speaking of residents, our Board of Directors today presented this month's Caller-Outer of the Month Award to Adam Fein, MD, a second year medical resident. Regular readers will recall that this award is presented by the Board to reinforce the underlying concept of BIDMC SPIRIT -- that each person should be encouraged to call out problems in the workplace and be recognized and appreciated for his or her contribution to safety, quality, efficiency, and a better work environment.

One of the annoying things about leaving a hospital is that the discharge process often takes a long time, leading to frustration for both patients and families. Adam diagnosed a source of those delays: The residents who were arranging follow-up appointments with hospital-based specialists were calling each specialist's office one at a time. This discharge step was often the lowest priority for residents: After all, patients who were still sick and needed care would instead get their attention. Meanwhile, the healthier patients waiting to be discharged would, in fact, be waiting for the resident to make those follow-up appointments.

As it turns out, we have a service for referring physicians in the community who need to make appointments with our specialists. They send in their request to a centralized referral command center ("RefComm"), where a nurse acts as the liaison in setting up appointments and communicating with all parties. As a result of Adam's call-out, the RefComm service center was also made available to the residents. Instead of making all the follow-up arrangements themselves, they simply send an electronic request to the folks at RefComm, who take care of things. This frees up the residents to carry out their doctoring duties and accelerates the discharge planning process.

Adam received a congratulatory letter, plus second row dugout tickets to a Red Sox game of his choice.

Friday, June 12, 2009

SPIRIT delivers!


Our Department of Medicine interns offer their interpretation of the effectiveness of our BIDMC SPIRIT program in this skit. (The sound is a little unclear sometimes, but you'll get it!)

Tuesday, June 09, 2009

5S gets you organized to be Lean








As our merry band of senior executives and clinical leaders continued our course in Lean philosophy and techniques today, we were reminded of the foundational power of the 5S, often called the first step in workplace improvement: Sort, set in order, shine, standardize, sustain. The storyboards above give some examples of the applications of these from clinical locations at BIDMC as we have proceeded with BIDMC SPIRIT over the last several months. As you look at them, they seem common-sensical and easy, but it takes practice and training to notice the opportunities and implement this kind of improvement.

Friday, May 29, 2009

SEIU surveys the residents

This week, residents at our hospital received an email survey request from the SEIU. Does this mean the union is thinking about organizing the residents, or does it hope to obtain responses that would be helpful in a corporate campaign? Some residents wondered how SEIU has the resources to obtain their email addresses and also how it can afford to conduct this kind of survey. The answer, as I have noted before, is because it can.

Dear Residents of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center,

As part of its effort to organize hospital workers in Boston, 1199SEIU has been reaching out to residents and attendings to better understand the joys and challenges of working at academic medical centers in Boston. As the end of your residency is near, we would like to give you the opportunity to tell us about your own residency experience. We would appreciate your thoughts on compensation for your residency and a few current healthcare policy issues.


Please consider filling out the following survey; it is brief and shouldn’t take more than 5 minutes. Your name and personal information will be kept confidential. Responses will be compiled in the aggregate.

One resident wrote me the following note:

Should I respond to this survey and tell them the truth how enjoyable it truly is to work at BIDMC, how the salaries are fair for the market, and other generally positive things or would they simply use this to twist any words I said to the negative?

I feel that you have done a better than outstanding job at defending the management of this hospital through the budget crisis across the country and at being in touch with all employees about the day-to-day challenges of running a hospital; very much in the spirit of transparency, I think.

My gut tells me to toss the below e-mail in the garbage with an unsubscribe order, but my heart tells me to tell the positive truth. What should I do?

Of course, I made clear that this is a matter of personal preference. Here's the survey. Anyone can fill it out. I'll help you with the answers I would give:

Q. During your residency at BIDMC did you have the opportunity to negotiate you (sic) salary and/or benefits?
A. I believe that, under the national rules of residency selection, this is not permitted.

Q. Were you required to take a pay cut as part of the [BIDMC] budget cutbacks?
A. No, residents were exempt from any cuts. See here, paragraph 24.

Q. Should residents have been asked to take a pay cut as part of the budget cutbacks?
A. No, but is SEIU advocating a reduction in residents' pay? Ditto, paragraph 25.

Q. Do you think that BIDMC would respect employees' desire to form a union?
A. What do you mean by desire? Do you mean by a secret ballot election? Or do you mean under the SEIU's proposal to eliminate secret ballot elections or limit debate during elections? If the latter, how would you know what the employees' desire actually is?

Thursday, May 28, 2009

McAllen, Texas = Boston, Massachusetts

Thoughts as I go through the night prepping for my regular colonoscopy (OK, more than you want to know!) which allows me to be up even earlier than usual and make some observations. I can't yet blame the soon-to-be administered Demerol for any incomprehensible wanderings, and I promise not to write the next post until that wears off.

Atul Gawande has yet another beautifully written article in the New Yorker about health care costs, this time focusing on a particular city in Texas that has remarkably high costs compared to the rest of the country. Of course, he need not have travelled so far. The points he raises have been published for years by our colleagues at Dartmouth, and have been discussed by Brent James and others. And the kinds of numbers he cites, although perhaps not as extreme, also typify health care costs here in Massachusetts.

Brent summarized some of these issues in a talk he gave here about a year ago:

-- Well-documented massive variation in practice based on local medical myths.
-- High rates of inappropriate care.
-- Unacceptable rates of preventable care-associated patient injury and death. (Hospitals are actually the #4 or #5 major public health problem in this regard!)
-- A striking inability to "do what we know works".
-- Huge amounts of waster and spiraling prices that limit access.

While Atul focuses on national policy in his article, let me bring the discussion back to strategic planning for hospitals in general and academic medical centers in particular. It seems to me that there are three overwhelming public policy trends in America:

1) A desire to set an annual budget per person for health care;
2) A desire to limit the growth of that annual budget to a rate equal to or less than the overall rate of inflation; and
3) A desire to reduce the amount of harm caused to patients during hospitalizations.

The successful hospitals (and their associated physicians) will be those who learn to live within these broad formulations, and the most successful with be those who wholeheartedly embrace them. Further, they will need to create integrated networks of care -- whether by ownership or strategic alliances -- with people in other parts of the health care delivery system who have similar beliefs. Finally, they will need to engage in process improvement of the type discussed by Steven Spear to squeeze waste out of the system on the "factory floor."

In Massachusetts, there is only one integrated delivery system characterized by ownership of enough entities to engage in this kind of strategic approach, but that system has not yet demonstrated an ability to deliver care at a lower cost. Indeed, just the opposite. For a place like BIDMC, we will have to rely on finding multi-specialty groups, community hospitals, and others who share our vision of success through improving the quality and efficiency of our service, delivering care in the most appropriate settings, and constantly striving to be "the best at getting better."

Many of you have watched our progress here on this blog and on our corporate website as we feel our way along this path. One of our management techniques is transparency. It is based on a philosophy that you can't get better and you can't hold yourself accountable unless you are exceptionally public about what you do wrong, as well as what you do right. As I have noted elsewhere:

Transparency's major societal and strategic imperative is to provide creative tension within hospitals so that they hold themselves accountable. This accountability is what will drive doctors, nurses, and administrators to seek constant improvements in the quality and safety of patient care.

In this sense, transparency is a necessary but not sufficient element in bringing about transformational change in an organization. But the actual implementation is not easy. You've seen our stories about BIDMC SPIRIT and Lean process improvement here. We view ourselves as babes in the woods in these arenas, but we view part of our role as an academic medical center to share what we have learned with others. We will also ruthlessly borrow good ideas from others in our quest to do better for our patients but also for ourselves as an organization facing the three policy imperatives set forth above.